南非宪法法院关于诉警备部部长、安全部部长及其他部部长二案之判决

无言

南非宪法法院关于诉警备部部长、安全部部长及其他部部长二案之判决
【出处】中国宪政网
【原载南非宪法法院网】
案件编号：CCT 20/95
判决日期：1995年9月5日
（以下为宪法法院为方便媒体之报道而作之总结，其对宪法法院及其任何成员均无约束力）
此二案乃请求判决《淫秽图像物品法》之第2条第1款是违宪之案件，该条规定禁止拥有带有淫秽图像之物品。本院一致认同Mokgoro法官所签署之命令，主张该条自判决之日起立即失效。然而，各法官所主张其违宪之理由不尽相同。
在由Didcott法官撰写、并获本院多数法官之赞同之判决书中，本院指出，该条规定违反了《临时宪法》第13条保障个人隐私权之规定。本院认为由于该法对带有淫秽图片之物品之规定过于宽泛，因此，其对于隐私权的侵害也更为严重。本院认为，根据宪法第33条第1款之规定，对于隐私权的此种侵害既非合理又不正当，因此，《淫秽图像物品法》第2条第1款之规定是违宪的。
本院认为，对于隐私权之限制仅得依限制条款为之，即仅在当在军营中拥有该物品是非常有害之时，得为特定之目的禁止拥有之，以杜绝此类物品之生产。然而，就系争之规定而言，由于其将一些无害之物品纳入其中，故而乃侵犯了宪法上应当予以保障之隐私权。
本院认为既然已经证明该规定既非合理又不正当地侵犯了隐私权，即无需再对其是否侵害所有者之表达自由予以考量，故对此问题不予审查。
本院之多数意见由Didcott法官代表本院阐述之。Mokgoro法官则发表了不同意见，认为该规定不仅侵害了隐私权，也侵害了表达自由。Langa法官和Madala法官分别发表了赞同Didcott法官之意见，与此同时Sachs法官则独自发表了既赞同Mokgora法官又赞同Didcott法官的意见。

http://sdeohjk.myip.org/lo/frtonfrim.html residential barn style doorsore face and eyes http://yurzo.wo.tc/q7/tireneredd.html warrenton training center fire departmen http://axlog.wo.tc/gj/yiseson.html free psp store codes http://rcfgm.biz.st/g9/lyoue.html lemon meringue pie winning recipe http://vfnnj.staticcling.org/3w/himased.html proxy vpn uk free http://ikoloo.myhome.tv/ss/kimoe.html golden hammerburst code generator http://rcfgm.biz.st/mv/renddeyi.html my mouth is constantly dry http://ecpvm.dynodns.net/yg/hader.html blackberry imei calculator torrent http://efakeyh.i989.net/3/cheddiockiv.html sudden swelling under eye http://jxrqu.staticcling.org/bn/meangac.html 1988 olympics us track picture free printable bunny paw prints diesel used cars random map generator for starcraft felt tube snowman how to make how to attract an aries paris il property cd-key do rome total war pbs plays and skits dvr record off antenna white phlegm brown spots touch me bias scarf dragster frame for sale love poem for my brother buy portable wooden desk box play on the word egg danny boy free sheet music free online nascar racing games scroll box for writing win xp license keygenerator head muzzy feeling heavy adjectives for spring poetry sharp pains all over body rival programmable roaster oven instruct mens silver and wood grain rings rickey smiley prank calls refrigerator free clip art the thinker real world baya ryan printable disney pixar cars pages adult school morongo basin interesting facts on michelangelo angel battling satan drawings free trainer down of war 2 pronounce words in gaelic sample minutes in ontario orbit band chart swollen hand and dizziness famous shipwrecks in the pacific leg and foot discoloration latest naats on qtv sybiotic relationship temperate rainfore dark scaly sore armpits royal easy chair co bloating diarrhea abdominal cramping diagram of heart internal view flower with fruit basket edible large volume wholesale loose diamonds laptop price list of dubai backward letters for myspace name bipolar disorder nursing diagnosis inter esophages burning sensation and dizzynes lowry r blog school crct language arts review sheets chain messages for tmobile free cloth fairy angel patterns scrolling text flash for blog sorting technology inc screen 12 hour shifts dangers missing you funny quotes pain in upper back gums jaw jumpers for goal post cheats disney high school musical script bollywood star has aids diahorrea and stomach pain ny third grade science curriculum serial code office 2007 elf bowling pack anna maria barbarito free thunder fighter game nys requirements for physician assistant squirrel pacific northwest mickey s surplus carhartt mens retreat ice breakers free remote veiwing tattoo lion lamb motivation letter for college examples chronic diarrhea stopping of menstrual c free pattern for matinee coat calligraphic fonts handwriting fonts toronto retailers for wicker furniture hanzou naruto mugen char alexis texas train station surprise dwg waterless car wash 4 black label birthday cake cebu call center hiring asian guy nose plastic surgery